Car News

Volkswagen apologises for poor handling of DSG recall

Volkswagen’s handling of the DSG gearbox and other problems has almost become a case history on how not to handle customer dissatisfaction. It seems they may have learnt a valuable, albeit expensive, lesson.

By Paul Murrell

John White is the managing director of Volkswagen Group Australia. It’s probably fair to say that since he assumed the role in April this year, his has been a baptism of fire. Even before he took up the role, he was being emailed by dissatisfied Australian customers, seeking answers to their VW woes.

After some resistance, the company finally instituted a recall after a young woman was killed in Melbourne when her VW Golf was rear-ended by a truck on the Monash Freeway in 2011. Witnesses reported that the car slowed dramatically, without the brake lights activating and sparked complaints from other owners whose VWs had cut out or stopped on busy roads, reportedly due to a faulty gearbox operation. VW Jetta, Golf, Polo, Passat and Caddy models built between June 2008 and September 2011 were recalled, as were 1700 Skoda vehicles and 6000 Audi A1 and A3 models.

Major concerns were voiced that VW Australia had been tardy in recalling the vehicles, particularly since vehicles had been subject to a recall much earlier in Japan, Singapore and China. Some of the issues with the DSG gearbox had been addressed in the United States as early as 2009.

Comprehensive Car Insurance

Another longstanding issue for VW owners has been a problem with the injectors on diesel engines. In Britain, the Vehicle and Operator Service Agency pushed Volkswagen into contacting customers and repaying thousands of pounds spent repairing faulty injectors. Despite being aware of the issue, VW waited until this year to begin a “silent” campaign in Australia to fix the problem. The matter was addressed only when a customer took their car in for a service at an authorised repair centre; owners who were having their cars repaired elsewhere were very much left to their own devices.

For some inexplicable reason, Volkswagen in Australia tried to keep a lid on the problem but once word started to spread, the reaction was swift and inevitable.

Now it seems the lesson has been learnt and VW is taking steps to ensure that it never arises again.

At the launch of the VW Golf GTI in Launceston in early October, John White faced assembled media to deliver a corporate “mea culpa”. He admitted that the dealer infrastructure in Australia has failed to keep pace with the remarkable growth of the brand and promised increased service capacity and improved dealer coverage in rural areas. “I acknowledge from a customer perspective, we need to do better,” he began. “My assessment is that, number one, we need to have quicker resolution of product issues. We are establishing new processes to do that. I have instructed our team to be more flexible with customers who have important issues, and recalled one of our management team from overseas to come back in the role of Customer First Manager. This person is presently putting together a set of standards and processes for all dealers to follow, so we have a more consistent customer experience across the network and a strong focus on training and dealer qualification.”

That kind of admission is not easy to make, and the personable John White should be commended for taking positive action to address the concerns of his customers. Some would argue that this action should have been taken earlier, and many VW customers have been vocal in calling it “too little, too late”.

The recent extension to five year warranties covering transmissions goes some way to allaying customer concerns, but the damage to the brand goes deep. Since dealers are the first point of contact for most owners, they need to understand the need to address problems quickly, honestly and transparently, and they have a right to expect the parent company to support them.

Volkswagen paid a high price for their attitude. According to figures released in early July, VW sold 1226 fewer cars than in the same period last year, a 19 percent drop in a market that has grown by 5.5 percent. Golf and Jetta sales were even harder hit, falling by more than 50 percent. At the October GTI launch, John White was able to report that VW sales had resumed the numbers achieved last year, with the primary sales drivers being Amarok, Transporter, Polo and Up!. He suggested that the group would aim for “more temperate, more moderate growth”.

There is a lesson here for all motor companies. Trust takes a long time to establish and can be quickly undermined. A car is a major purchase, usually the second largest any of us ever have to make. Volkswagen failed to treat its customers with the respect they deserved and they must now start the long climb back to regain the trust and loyalty they squandered so profligately.


6 Comments

  1. Will
    November 15, 2013 at 10:07 am — Reply

    I bought a new Polo Gti in 2011. In the proceedng 2 years the car has been plagued with major faults 3 gearboxes, a clutch and engine problems. VW Australia offered to purchase the car back from but at way under market value. The car now sits with engine and transm,ission faults that cannot be repaired by VW Austrlalia and yet they refuse to offer a reasonable buy back figure. Vw Germany have been notified but simply do not want to know defferring the matter back to VW Austrlalia who sit on the hands and do nothing.
    Is this reasonable of Vw Austrlalia

    • November 17, 2013 at 7:05 am — Reply

      Hi Will, and thanks for your note. It does sound like an unfortunate situation and I can well imagine your frustration. Let’s take this offline; do you mind contacting me (Isaac – editor) at isaacb(at)practicalmotoring.com.au and we can talk more about it.

  2. concerned
    October 14, 2014 at 9:28 pm — Reply

    I have a fleet of 9 vehicles and I’m finding mixed results from my VW’s (5) compared to some of my Hyundai’s, as soon as the VW’s get to the magic 5 year age they just start to become a maintenace issue, I’m currently in the market to replace two of my fleets (VW’s) Transporter and Tiguan and it will all come down to how VW handles an early failure of one of my vehicles DSG gear boxes, if I return for another two VW’s or go to another brand which offers 5 years warranty over the standard 3 year warranty offered by VW, don’t get me wrong I love my VW’s but reliability of the VW product is not great, and the horror stories are out there.

    • October 15, 2014 at 9:31 am — Reply

      Hi Concerned, I think it sounds like you’ve already made up your mind? My old man had a Transporter which never missed a beat in the 10 years he owned it, but… You’re in the perfect position to assess your next vehicle choice. Besides the DSG what sort of maintenance issues have you had?
      My personal car is a Skoda Octavia with a DSG and it’s never had a problem, but you’re right, there are plenty of horror stories. But I think every brand has its fair share of those, but the VW DSG dramas have been well documented.
      Do let us know which way you decide to go. Cheers Isaac (editor).

    • October 15, 2014 at 10:12 am — Reply

      Hi Concerned, I think it sounds like you’ve already made up your mind? My old man had a Transporter which never missed a beat in the 10 years he owned it, but… You’re in the perfect position to assess your next vehicle choice. Besides the DSG what sort of maintenance issues have you had?
      My personal car is a Skoda Octavia with a DSG and it’s never had a problem, but you’re right, there are plenty of horror stories. But I think every brand has its fair share of those, but the VW DSG dramas have been well documented.
      Do let us know which way you decide to go. Cheers Isaac (editor).

  3. Ray Vella
    February 7, 2017 at 5:07 pm — Reply

    VOLKSWAGON DSG DUD.
    In 2010 I purchased a vw golf tsi. The car was a 2009 model. The DSG gearbox started jerking very badly at about 42000kl. I took it back for the recall in 2013 and they said they were
    “Doing me a favour” when their product was defective. Mechatronics replacement We are now in early 2017, the car doesn’t drive anymore due to a ” mechatronics malfunction “. Volkswagen now want $4000 to fix the same recall problem. ARE YOU KIDDING!!! Stay away from these dud cars. Even though they are supposedly extending the warranty the gearbox will still fail and if it is after the warranty,GOOD LUCK

Leave a reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Isaac Bober

Isaac Bober

Isaac Bober was born in the shadow of Mount Panorama in Bathurst and, so, it was inevitable he’d fall into work as a motoring writer. He began his motoring career in 2000 reviewing commercial vehicles, before becoming editor of Caravan & Motorhome magazine. He then moved to MOTOR Magazine before going freelance and contributing to Overlander 4WD, 4×4 Australia, TopGear Australia, Men’s Health, Men’s Fitness, The Australian, CARSguide, and many more.